# Risk Acceptance Decision Framework

- **PURPOSE:** Establishes a structured approach for evaluating, documenting, and approving decisions to accept security risks, ensuring appropriate accountability and visibility.
- **WHEN TO USE:** When security risks cannot be fully mitigated and formal risk acceptance decisions must be made, particularly for risks that exceed standard tolerance levels.

## RISK DETAILS

**Risk ID**[From risk register]

**Risk Description**[Copy from risk register]

**Business Context**[Describe affected business process/service]

**Risk Owner**[Name and position]

## RISK ASSESSMENT

**Inherent Risk Rating**[High/Medium/Low or numerical score]

**Current Controls**[List existing controls]

**Residual Risk Rating**[High/Medium/Low or numerical score]

**Potential Business Impact**[Describe and quantify where possible] 

**Financial impact**[X−X- X−Y estimated range] 

**Operational impact**[Describe potential disruption]

**Reputational impact**[Describe potential damage]

**Regulatory impact**[Describe potential violations]

## ACCEPTANCE RATIONALE

**Business Justification**[Why accepting this risk is the appropriate response]

**Alternatives Considered**[What other options were evaluated and why they were rejected]

**Cost-Benefit Analysis**[Compare cost of additional controls vs. potential loss]

## ACCEPTANCE TERMS

**Acceptance Period**[Start date] to [End date] (not to exceed [X] months)

**Compensating Controls**[Temporary controls to be implemented during acceptance period]

**Monitoring Requirements**[How the risk will be monitored during acceptance]

**Reassessment Triggers**[Events that would prompt earlier reassessment]

## APPROVAL 

Based on the authorization levels below, this risk acceptance requires approval from: [Determine required approvers based on chart below]

| Risk Level | Maximum Acceptance Period | Required Approvers | Documentation Requirements |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Low | 12 months | • Business Unit Manager\n\n• Security Manager | • Basic risk details\n\n• Simple justification |
| Medium | 6 months | • Business Unit Director\n\n• CISO/Security Director\n\n• Risk Committee review | • Detailed risk assessment\n\n• Business justification\n\n• Compensating controls |
| High | 3 months | • Business Unit Executive\n\n• CISO\n\n• CIO/CTO\n\n• Risk Committee approval | • Comprehensive risk analysis\n\n• Business case\n\n• Monitoring plan\n\n• Remediation timeline |
| Critical | 1 month (emergency only) | • C-Suite Executive\n\n• CISO\n\n• Board/Risk Committee notification | • Complete risk documentation\n\n• Executive summary\n\n• Detailed remediation plan\n\n• Weekly status reporting |

Table 1: Risk Acceptance Authorization Levels

## IMPLEMENTATION TIPS:

- Ensure risk acceptance decisions are time-bound with clear expiration dates
- Create a central repository for all risk acceptance decisions for tracking and review
- Review all active risk acceptances quarterly to ensure conditions haven't changed

***

(c)[Kayne McGladrey](https://kaynemcgladrey.com/) - [Get the full book "Cyber Risk is a Myth"](https://www.routledge.com/Cyber-Risk-is-a-Myth-A-Business-Approach-to-Integrated-Risk-Management/McGladrey/p/book/9781041249054)